DISTINCTION BETWEEN AN IMMORAL OFFENCE AND A VIOLATION OF ACADEMIC INTEGRITY: LEGAL PROBLEMS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31359/2311-4894-2019-28-4-40Keywords:
immoral offence, academic integrity, pedagogical worker, scientific pedagogical worker, moral rulesAbstract
Problem setting. It was found: Ukraine legislation has two similar reasons to dismiss the worker – an immoral offence and a violation of academic integrity that causes some problems in law enforcement because the legislator has based these terms on a moral criterion.
Target research. The purpose of the article is making a science research about difference between such terms as «immoral offence» and «violation of academic integrity» by analyzing the structures of an immoral offence and a violation of academic integrity.
Analysis of recent researches and publications. Immoral offence and its legal nature was an object of scientific research of many scientists (between them there are H. S. Honcharova, R. V. Huban, V. F. Puzyrnyi, O. V. Tyshchenko, O. V. Supruniuk, N. M. Shvets and others). Y. M. Bezhuk, N. H. Maslova, Y. O. Tytska have been analyzing a concept of violation of the academic integrity as an element of the quality of education. Their works are a good basis for our legal research.
Article’s main body. Concepts of the immoral offence and the violation of academic integrity was analyzed in the article. These legal terms have differences in its subject, object and objective party but they are similar in its subjective party. Also, the violation of academic integrity is a disciplinary offence when the immoral offence is not.
Conclusions and prospects of development. National legislation of Ukraine has some problems in dismissing a worker who performs educational functions. In this way, it is important to amend the law «About education» by providing such academic responsibility as dismissal and adding objective criteria of determining reasons of such dismissal.
References
Kostyuchenko O. Ye. (2018) Realizaciya socialnogo priznachennya trudovogo prava v Ukrayini. Kharkiv: Pravo [in Ukrainian]
Suprunyuk O. V. Komparativistsko-pravove doslidzhennya zvilnennya za amoralnij prostupok. Aktualni problemi derzhavi i prava – Actual Problems of State and Law. (Kivalov S. V., Dromin V. M., Alenin Yu. P. et all. Eds.); MON Ukrayini; NU OYuA. Odesa : Yurid. l-ra,. Vip. 74. 81‒89 [in Ukrainian]
Pro osvitu: Zakon Ukrayini vid 05.09.2017 r. № 2145-VIII. (2017) Vidomosti Verhovnoyi Radi Ukrayini – Supreme Council of Ukraine. №38‒39. St. 380 [in Ukrainian]
Pro praktiku rozglyadu sudami trudovihsporiv: Postanova Plenumu Verhovnogo Sudu vid 06.11.1992 № 9. URL: http://zakon2.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/v0009700-92 [in Ukrainian]
Tishenko O.V. (2002) Pravovi problemi ukladennya, zmini ta pripinennya trudovogo dogovoru z pedagogichnimi pracivnikami serednih zagalnoosvitnih shkil Ukrayini. Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis. Kiyiv: Nac. un-t im. T.Shevchenka. Kyiv [in Ukrainian]
Popova-Koryak K.O. (2017) Amoralnij prostupok, nesumisnij z prodovzhennyam naukovo-pedagogichnim pracivnikom svoyeyi roboti, yak pidstava pripinennya trudovogo dogovoru. Elektronne naukove fahove vidannya «Porivnyalno-analitichne pravo» – Electronic scientific professional publication «Comparative-analytical law», 4, 141‒145 [in Ukrainian]
Puzirnij V. F. (2018) Rozirvannya trudovogo dogovoru u vipadku vchinennya pracivnikom amoralnogo prostupku. Aktualni problemi yuridichnoyi nauki ta praktiki – Actual problems of legal science and practice, 1 (4), 63‒67 [in Ukrainian]
Shvec N. M. (2011) Pravovi aspekti zvilnennya pracivnika za amoralnij prostupok. Problemi zakonnosti – Problems of legality, Vip. 113, 83‒91 [in Ukrainian]
Postanova Verhovnogo Sudu Ukrayini vid 22.03.2017 r. u spravi №757/4906/15-c. URL: http://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/65627377 [in Ukrainian]
Goncharova G. S. (1985). Umovi pripinennya trudovogo dogovoru u zv’yazku z vchinennyam amoralnogo prostupku. Radyanske pravo – Soviet Law, 2, 64–68 [in Ukrainian]
Maleina M. N. (2018). Amoralnyj prostupok prepodavatelya: pravovaya ocenka ponyatiya i posledstvij v sfere trudovogo i grazhdanskogo prava. Zhurnal rossijskogo prava – Journal of Russian Law, 10, 61‒72 [in Ukrainian]
Slovnik ukrayinskoyi movy (Vols.1-11). (Bilodid I. K. Ed.). Kiyiv, 1970–1980 [in Ukrainian]
Shodo rekomendacij z akademichnoyi dobrochesnosti dlya zakladiv vishoyi osviti: list Ministerstva osviti i nauki Ukrayini vid 23.10.2018 r. № 1/9-650. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/rada/show/v-650729-18 [in Ukrainian]
Polozhennya pro komisiyu z akademichnoyi etiki Nacionalnogo yuridichnogo universitetu imeni Yaroslava Mudrogo: nakaz rektora № 204 vid 31.08.2018 r. URL: https://nlu.edu.ua/files/norm_doc/Polozhennia_komisiyu_acad_etyky.pdf [in Ukrainian]
Polozhennya «Pro akademichnu dobrochesnist ta etiku akademichnih vzayemovidnosin u Sumskomu derzhavnomu universiteti»:nakaz rektora № 9160-I vid 22.02.2019 r. URL: https://library.sumdu.edu.ua/data/polozh_akad_dobr.pdf [in Ukrainian]
Pro zagalnu serednyu osvitu: Zakon Ukrayini vid 13.05.1999 r. № 651-XIV. (1999) Vidomosti Verhovnoyi Radi Ukrayini – Supreme Council of Ukraine, 28, art. 230 [in Ukrainian]
Pro vishu osvitu: Zakon Ukrayini vid 01. 07. 2014 r. (2014) Vidomosti Verhovnoyi Radi Ukrayini – Supreme Council of Ukraine, 37–38, art. 2004 [in Ukrainian]
Pro zatverdzhennya pereliku posad pedagogichnih ta naukovo-pedagogichnih pracivnikiv: Postanova Kabinetu ministriv Ukrayini vid 14.06.2000 № 963. (2000) Oficijnij visnik Ukrayini – Official Bulletin of Ukraine, 24, art. 1015 [in Ukrainian]
Pro naukovu ta naukovo-tehnichnu-diyalnist: Zakon Ukrayini vid 26.11.2015 r. № 848-VIII. (2016) Vidomosti Verhovnoyi Radi Ukrayini – Supreme Council of Ukraine, 3, art. 25 [in Ukrainian]
Puzirnij V. F. (2019) Pravovi problemi rozirvannya trudovogo dogovoru u vipadku vchinennya pracivnikom amoralnogo prostupku. Problemi realizaciyi prav gromadyan u sferi praci ta socialnogo zabezpechennya: tezi dop. ta nauk. povidoml. uchasnikiv IH Mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf., yaka prisvyach. 50-richchyu stvorennya kafedri trud. prava Nac. yurid. un-tu im. Yaroslava Mudrogo – Problems of realization of citizens’ rights in the sphere of labor and social security: abstracts of supplement. and science. message participants of the IX International. scientific-practical conf. 50th Anniversary of the Department of Labor Law of Yaroslav Mudryi National Law University. Pravo. 108 – 111 [in Ukrainian]
Akademichna chesnist yak osnova stalogo rozvitku universitetu. (Finikova T.V., Artyuhova A.Ye. Eds.) (2016) Kiyiv; Takson [in Ukrainian]
