Evolution of a legal entity: from property separation to the right to privacy

Authors

  • Sofiia Popova PhD in Law, Senior lecturer at the Department of Civil Law and Procedure of Faculty № 6 of the Kharkiv National University of Internal Affairs , доктор філософії у галузі «Право», старший викладач кафедри цивільного права та процесу факультету № 6 Харківського національного університету внутрішніх справ https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3628-1513 (unauthenticated)

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.37772/2518-1718-2024-1(45)-8

Keywords:

legal entity, corporation, legal personality, property, property independence, property separation, responsibility, personal non-property rights, right to privacy

Abstract

Problem setting. The perception of the legal status of a legal entity is changing, a legal entity acquires rights not inherent to it before and participates in legal relations that are not inherent to it. These statements cause many scientific discussions. Analysis of recent researches and publications. Many domestic scientists dealt with the problems of genesis and the sign of a legal entity. Among which Yu.M. Zhornokui, V.I. Borisova, Zozuliak O.I., Oliynyk O.S., S.O. Popova, O.V. Artykulenko and others. The topic of the development of the institute of a legal entity is always relevant due to the fact that the legal entity plays an important role in improving the economic indicators of the state, which, at the same time, contributes to the improvement of this institute and causes the emergence of new discussions and research. The purpose of the research is to study the evolution of a legal entity as an independent subject of law and to determine its possibility of acquiring the right to privacy. Article’s main body. The article is devoted to the study of evolution, that is, the gradual development of the essence of a legal entity in legal relations. It was determined that the legal entity has gone a long way in its transformation from its perception as a fiction to an independent subject of legal relations. Recognizing the real property separation of the organization meant literally perceiving a legal entity as something different from a natural person, but at the same time, not as a group of many, but as a whole person. Studies of the evolution of a legal entity from property separation to the right to privacy mark certain periods in the research of the essence of a legal entity and its formation as an independent subject of law with the ability to acquire and exercise a diverse set of rights. In accordance with the law, a legal entity is endowed with legal personality. A legal entity is a dynamic entity in objective reality, that is, which exists independently of physical embodiment and is not only the name of a participant in legal relations. It was determined that in the modern world, a legal entity can be recognized as a person with the presence of an intangible sphere. The possibility of a legal entity acquiring such a personal non-property right as the right to privacy, which means the ability to prevent unauthorized disclosure of sensitive, confidential or compromising information, is analyzed. Conclusions and prospects for the development. Distinguishing the sign of property separation and the possibility of acquiring the right to privacy is important. Thanks to this research, we can show the stage when a legal entity was just beginning its path to acquiring legal personality, and could also be considered equal to a natural person. Separating the property of the organization as the property of an individual from the property of a natural person (persons) who is a member of a legal entity is the starting point for not recognizing the anthropomorphizing influence (that is, the influence of a natural person who seems to be behind and controls all processes). Today, a legal entity acquires personal non-property rights, including the right to privacy, separate from the right of individuals. After all, the organization also has its internal “secrets” and has the right to protect them.

References

The Civil Code of Ukraine, No. 435-IV (2003, January 1). Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/43515 [in Ukrainian].

Oliynyk, O.S. (2023) Conceptual aspects of reforming the institution of a legal entity under the conditions of recodification of the Civil Code of Ukraine. Actual problems of improving of current legislation of Ukraine, No 61, 2.96-2.108 [in Ukrainian].

Oginova, I.O. (2011) Evolution Theory (System Development of Life in Earth): primer. Dnipropetrovsk: Dnipropetrovsk University Press [in Ukrainian].

Borisova, V. (2001) Theories of the essence of a legal entity: history and modernity. Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, 4(27), 117–130 [in Ukrainian].

Ngaire, N. Who Are Law’s Persons? From Cheshire Cats to Responsible Subjects. The Modern Law Review, Vol. 66, No. 3 (May, 2003), 346–367.

Suchasni problemy tsyvilnoho prava ta protsesu (2017) (Ed. Zhornokui Yu. M., Krasytska, L. V.). Kharkiv. Law. 808 c. [in Ukrainian].

Zhornokui, Yu.M., Zhornokui, V.H. Siadrysta, I.I. (2018) Economic composition of legal entity: modern state and features. Financial and credit activity: problems of theory and practice, 3, 394–401 [in Ukrainian].

Borisova, V. (2010) Institute of a legal entity in the law of Ukraine. Law of Ukraine, 12, 25–31 [in Ukrainian].

Artykulenko, O.V. (2018) Legal personality of a legal entity: contemporary challenges and unresolved issues. Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law, 6, 238–242 [in Ukrainian].

Zozuliak, O. (2023) Approaches of understanding the contract as a form of realization legal personality of participants in civil legal relations. Private law and entrepreneurship, 22. 23–29 [in Ukrainian].

The Resolution of the Joint Chamber of the Civil Cassation Court of the Supreme Court of the case of № 504/4099/16ц (2023 December 11) Retrieved from: https://reyestr.court.gov.ua/Review/115750120 [in Ukrainian].

Popova, S. (2023) Personal non-property rights of a legal entity: today’s realities. Kharkiv: Pravo [in Ukrainian].

Smith, B. (1928). Legal Personality. The Yale Law Journal, Vol. 37, No. 3, 283–299. 14. Kardash, A.V. (2017) The right to privacy as the basic human right. Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law, No 47, 76–80 [in Ukrainian].

Published

2024-09-02